Critique of Research Studies -- Part 1
Shiji Ben Philip
Health Care Exploration Analysis and Utilization
Doctor Eva Hvingelby
November 30, 2014
The title from the article is usually " A result of supplemental sensory stimulation system as an adjunct to developmental support program in high risk infants” written by Namitha Shenai and Jyothika In Bijilani (Shenai & Bijlani, 2013). Relating to Polit and Beck, an effective subject should entice the readers by simply including the centered variables, impartial variables as well as the population examined. Also it should never contain much more than 15 phrases (Polit & Beck, 2008). Since the title of the document contains the two dependent and independent variable and the population included in the research, the title can be viewed effective. Subjective
The abstract with the article offers explained the goal and aims of the examine, the methods, effects, conclusion plus the abbreviations utilized in the article. The abstract is organised using sub headings as well as the reader will get a clear idea about the study under every single heading and hence give a crystal clear and specific summary from the article. Advantages
Disability in the sensory processing ends in developmental and functional afflictions in human beings. Thee infants in a NICU are at higher risk of having the disorganized pattern of behavioral and emotional reactions due to sacrificed neurological and biological system (Shenai & Bijlani, 2013). These jeopardized neurological and biological systems will result in Physical processing malfunction (SPD) during these infants (Shenai & Bijlani, 2013) Hence the problem is relevant and requires a quantitative method to study. Consequently it is inevitable to evaluate and manage these high-risk babies effectively and so the study can be significant to nursing. 55 explained plainly in the intro part of the article and the declaration fulfills the needs needed. Ideas or Exploration Questions
The article obviously states the hypotheses from the study within bold going. There are two hypotheses to get the study, a null speculation H0 and an alternative speculation H1. The null speculation was that the supplemental sensory stimulation is definitely not powerful in early childhood delayed babies (Shenai & Bijlani, 2013). The alternative speculation was that the sensory stimulation is effective in developmentally postponed infants. (Shenai & Bijlani, 2013) The hypotheses had been relevant to the research done and state the relation between your variables. Literary works Review
The writers have detailed three materials reviews in the article. Two of them had been from the nineties and one particular was in the year 1979. Even though the studies were highly relevant to the problem and explain a review of the problem as well as the need for examine, they are not up to date. The summary in the literature review is not good enough to get a deeper knowledge about the literature. The authors needs to have done more elaborated justification of the evidences of the problem in the literature. Conceptual and Assumptive Framework
The article does not provide a assumptive or conceptual framework pertaining to the study. Although a theoretical background will not support the research, the purpose of the research is significant to the nursing field and offers a precise intervention. But the absence of a theoretical construction develops a conceptual fuzziness to the research (Polit & Beck, 2008).
Qualitative Study Title
The article selected for the qualitative research is " Engagement: a great indicator of difference in the perceptions of antenatal look after pregnant women coming from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds” by Angie Docherty, Carol Bugge and Claire Watterson (Docherty et 's., 2012). The title itself details the purpose of the analysis and the population involved in the analyze. thus giving you a vivid...
References: Shenai, N. G., & Bijlani, J. D. (2013, Might 1). Effect of supplemental physical stimulation system as a great adjunct to developing support put in high-risk newborns. The Indian Journal of Occupational Remedy, 45(2), 21-27. Retrieved from http://eds.a.ebscohost.com.library.gcu.edu:
Docherty, A., Bugge, C., & Watterson, A. (2012, Summer 1). Engagement: an sign of big difference in the perceptions of antenatal care for pregnant women from various socioeconomic backgrounds. Health Anticipations, 15(2), 126-138. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1369-7625.2011.00684.x
Polit, D. E., & Beck, C. Big t. (2012). Medical Research: Generating and Evaluating Evidence Pertaining to Nursing Practice (9th male impotence. ). PA: Wolters Kluwer/Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.